Did Big Mom Eat Mother Carmel? – Detailed Guide

Did Big Mom Eat Mother Carmel, In the world of One Piece, there are many mysteries surrounding the characters and their pasts. One such enigma revolves around the relationship between Big Mom and Mother Carmel. Big Mom, also known as Charlotte Linlin, is one of the Four Emperors, the most powerful pirates in the world. Mother Carmel, on the other hand, is a former pirate and a renowned child trafficker. This article delves into the question: Did Big Mom eat Mother Carmel?

Who is Big Mom?

Big Mom, also known as Charlotte Linlin, is one of the most formidable pirates in the world of One Piece. She is the captain of the Big Mom Pirates and rules over Totto Land, a massive territory comprising various islands. Big Mom possesses tremendous physical strength and is a fearsome adversary in battle. She is also known for her insatiable appetite and unique ability to use Homies, which are objects infused with souls.

Read Also: How Many Inches Are 5 Feet

Who is Mother Carmel?

Mother Carmel, also known as “Mountain Witch” Carmel, is a former pirate and the founder of the infamous Sheep’s House, an orphanage for abandoned and unwanted children. She was revered as a saint-like figure and was believed to possess the power of miracles. Mother Carmel’s influence extended to the World Government, allowing her to operate without hindrance.

The Mysterious Incident

The pivotal event that raises questions about Big Mom and Mother Carmel revolves around a mysterious incident known as the “Tea Party.” During this event, Big Mom and Mother Carmel were present along with various dignitaries, including members of the World Government. However, the Tea Party ended in chaos and bloodshed, and Mother Carmel was never seen again.

Did Big Mom Eat Mother Carmel?

The prevailing theory is that Big Mom indeed ate Mother Carmel during the Tea Party. This theory is supported by several pieces of evidence and Big Mom’s known cannibalistic nature.

Supporting Evidence

  1. Carmel’s Disappearance: Mother Carmel’s sudden and unexplained disappearance after the Tea Party suggests that something nefarious occurred. Big Mom’s presence and her subsequent cannibalistic tendencies raise suspicions about her involvement in Carmel’s vanishing.
  2. Big Mom’s Cannibalistic Nature: Big Mom is known for her insatiable appetite, which extends to consuming her own family members. She has an overwhelming craving for sweets and has been shown to devour anything in her path when her craving intensifies.
  3. Prometheus and Zeus: Big Mom possesses two powerful Homies, Prometheus and Zeus. These Homies were created from the souls of two individuals, potentially hinting at their dark fate under Big Mom’s control.

Opposing Theories

While the prevailing theory suggests that Big Mom ate Mother Carmel, there are alternative explanations that challenge this notion.

  1. Carmel’s Survival: Some speculate that Mother Carmel may have survived the Tea Party incident and went into hiding. It is argued that her disappearance was a ruse orchestrated to escape from her criminal past.
  2. Manipulation of Memories: Another theory proposes that Big Mom used her powers to manipulate the memories of those present at the Tea Party. This could explain the collective amnesia regarding Mother Carmel’s fate and preserve Big Mom’s image.


The truth behind the mysterious Tea Party incident and Mother Carmel’s fate remains shrouded in ambiguity. The prevailing theory suggests that Big Mom consumed Mother Carmel during the chaotic event, considering Big Mom’s cannibalistic nature and Carmel’s sudden disappearance. However, opposing theories propose Carmel’s survival or the manipulation of memories as alternate explanations. Until further revelations occur within the One Piece series, the question of whether Big Mom ate Mother Carmel will continue to intrigue fans.


Q1: Was Mother Carmel a good person?

Mother Carmel’s character is complex. While she was revered as a saint-like figure due to her charitable work at the Sheep’s House orphanage, her involvement in child trafficking raises ethical concerns about her true nature.

Q2: Is Big Mom a villain in the One Piece series?

Big Mom is considered one of the primary antagonists in the One Piece series. Her actions and pursuit of power align her with the role of a villain, as she poses a significant threat to the protagonists.

Q3: What are the consequences of eating a Devil Fruit in One Piece?

In the One Piece world, consuming a Devil Fruit grants the user superhuman abilities but results in the loss of the ability to swim. This drawback is significant since water is a natural weakness for Devil Fruit users.

Q4: How strong is Big Mom in the One Piece world?

Big Mom’s strength is immense, placing her among the most powerful characters in the One Piece universe. Her physical power, mastery of Haki, and the aid of her powerful Homies make her a formidable force to be reckoned with.

Q5: Will the truth behind Mother Carmel’s disappearance be revealed?

As with many mysteries in the One Piece series, it is likely that the truth behind Mother Carmel’s disappearance will eventually be unveiled. Eiichiro Oda, the creator of One Piece, is known for his meticulous storytelling, and fans eagerly await future revelations.

Leave a Comment